Italy Orders Meta to Change Facebook Gallery Suggestions After €805 Million Fine

src-a3bf89c2

Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta €805 million over a Facebook for Android feature that suggests photos and videos from a user’s phone gallery for posting. The Garante found that the feature was enabled by default and that the app accessed gallery content and related metadata without obtaining the explicit consent it said was required.

The authority’s decision has immediate compliance implications for Meta: it must change how the feature is presented and activated, including for users who have already granted Facebook access to their phone galleries. The order also sets reporting deadlines and says the feature cannot be enabled for users who have not provided valid consent if Meta misses the required 60-day deadline.

Why the permission design was challenged

According to the Garante, Facebook sought gallery access through a single device permission that covered the app and several functions with different purposes. A general notice about enabling other features appeared first, but the authority said it did not clearly explain that granting access would also enable photo and video suggestions.

Once granted, gallery permission can allow an app to read a phone’s photo archive, typically on an ongoing basis. The authority said neither users nor the regulator could verify which information was actually used. Its finding focused on access to information stored on the device, rather than establishing that gallery content had been transmitted elsewhere or caused harm.

The Garante found a violation of Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive in Italian law. The rule treats a phone as part of an individual’s private life and requires free and informed consent for access to information stored on it. In the authority’s interpretation, that requirement applies whether or not the information is subsequently sent anywhere.

Required changes and deadlines

Within 60 days, Meta must seek consent through a separate, specific request for the gallery-suggestion feature. The request must explain the feature’s purpose, disclose that it accesses the gallery and tell users how to turn it off. The feature must also remain disabled by default, including for people who have already granted Facebook gallery access.

Meta must report to the Garante within 30 days on work it has begun and provide a further report within 90 days on the measures taken. If the company fails to meet the 60-day deadline, it cannot activate the feature for anyone who has not given valid consent.

Meta plans to appeal and has called the fine “disproportionate,” according to a spokesperson’s statement reported by Reuters. The company said the feature works only after users grant permission on their device and that they can change that permission in their settings. The Garante’s order, however, addresses whether the permission and disclosures adequately communicate the separate purpose of gallery suggestions.

Investigation and enforcement context

The feature has been available since 2023. The Garante began its investigation in July 2025, following a complaint from the Bolzano consumer protection group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, and conducted its own technical analysis. The group published consumer advice on July 11, 2025, recommending that users disable gallery suggestions in the app and review Facebook’s phone permissions.

Meta argued that Ireland’s data protection authority should handle the case. The Garante rejected that position, reasoning that the ePrivacy rules at issue do not provide a one-stop-shop mechanism for determining which national authority handles enforcement.

The €805 million penalty is approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue. In setting the amount, the Garante considered the number of people affected—about 20 million Android users in Italy—and the duration of the violation. It said the issue remains ongoing for users who have not updated the app and for people who previously granted permission. The authority also cited a 2019 decision involving Meta and limited cooperation during the investigation. Changes made after the complaint counted in the company’s favor, but the Garante considered them late and limited to users who updated the app.

The investigation did not determine whether gallery content was used to train AI models; Meta denies such use. The Garante may separately examine a newer feature, launched this year, that allows gallery content to be processed in the cloud. That possibility is distinct from the findings in the current case.

What compliance teams should watch

The decision highlights the need to assess mobile permissions against the specific purposes they enable. A broad device-level grant may not, by itself, demonstrate that a user understood and agreed to each function relying on that access. Organizations should review whether consent requests clearly identify the relevant data, explain the feature’s purpose, provide a practical way to withdraw consent and avoid turning optional processing on by default.

For companies operating across jurisdictions, the case also underscores that privacy obligations can involve different legal frameworks and enforcement routes. Teams should track the Garante’s deadlines and any appeal, while recognizing that the current ruling concerns gallery access and consent—not the separate question of AI training or cloud processing.